Meet the Reclusive Software program Billionaire Attacking Elon Musk

“Trillion-Greenback Ponzi Scheme.”

“Deep Flaws.”


The tv advertisements for Dan O’Dowd, a software program billionaire operating as a Democrat for Senate in California, should not your typical marketing campaign spots. To a unprecedented diploma, they’re all aimed toward one matter: Tesla’s automated driving software program. Not at his putative opponent, Senator Alex Padilla, the incumbent Democrat.

O’Dowd’s marketing campaign slogan is “Making Computer systems Secure for Humanity.” Tesla’s computer systems, he claims, should not.

“The issue of the final 5 or 10 years has been that we’ve been taking the whole lot that our lives rely on and placing computer systems in command of it,” O’Dowd stated in an interview. “So now our energy grid, our vehicles, or our dams, or bridges, hospitals — the whole lot has been put in computer systems which have been put in command of the whole lot.”

He added: “And a number of the software program that was used to do this may be very poor high quality.”

O’Dowd’s preliminary focus, he stated, is on Tesla’s full self-driving software program, which he says ought to have by no means been allowed on the street.

“The software program that drives vehicles which might be going to have tens of millions of individuals relying on it needs to be our greatest software program, essentially the most fastidiously designed and examined software program,” he stated. “As a substitute we’re utilizing actually the worst software program.”

O’Dowd additionally ran a paid advert in a print version of The New York Instances, headlined “Don’t Be a Tesla Crash-Check Dummy.” The advert promotes The Daybreak Mission, O’Dowd’s web site highlighting his experience as a software program engineer for tasks just like the Boeing 787 and the Lockheed Martin F-35 fighter jet.

A few of O’Dowd’s critics have questioned the motives behind his anti-Tesla marketing campaign. Automotive firms use his firm’s software program in numerous elements and techniques, together with automated driving techniques.

For Democrats, Elon Musk, Tesla’s founder, makes for an inviting political quarry.

In latest weeks, Musk has shared his unsolicited ideas on politics, free speech, “cancel tradition,” his “hardcore litigation division” and anything that appears to cross his thoughts on Twitter. He has bashed the Democratic Occasion because the social gathering of “division and hate” and stated that he’ll now “vote Republican.”

Musk’s engagement in public debate has price him dearly. The worth of Tesla shares has dropped by practically $400 because the information first emerged in early April that he had taken a stake in Twitter, which he has since agreed to buy.

Tesla didn’t reply to a request for remark for this text. On its web site, the corporate says that its full self-driving system requires “lively driver supervision” and doesn’t “make the car autonomous.”

However Musk has at instances implied in any other case. “I’m extremely assured the automobile will drive itself for the reliability in extra of a human this 12 months,” he stated in January 2021. “This can be a very massive deal.”

After I requested O’Dowd why he had taken the unorthodox route of operating for workplace, somewhat than beginning a nonprofit and easily elevating the difficulty within the public area, he stated he had taken that method already.

“I’ve tried practically the whole lot,” he stated. “I’ve tried going to the federal government, to the regulators, to the politicians, to the businesses themselves.”

“I’ve been giving speeches for seven years, feeling somewhat lonely,” he stated. However now that his campaign towards Tesla has gotten intensive protection, he added, “I’ve not been feeling so lonely.”

If the state of California or another authorized authority decrees that Tesla’s self-driving software program is just not prepared for public use, he’ll “shut up,” he stated.

However for now, O’Dowd is prepared to spend “no matter it takes” to realize his purpose of taking it off the market, he stated. “An entire raft of extra commercials” are within the works.

“I don’t have a price range,” he stated matter-of-factly.

O’Dowd is totally self-funding his marketing campaign. He has already spent practically $3.5 million on advertisements, excess of some other candidate within the race. His marketing campaign supervisor is Jon Blair, a veteran Democratic strategist who beforehand helped elect Gina Raimondo, the previous governor of Rhode Island.

He’s additionally employed Mark Putnam, a Democratic ad-maker whose agency has turn into well-known for making gauzy biographical movies for candidates, together with spots for Amy McGrath and M.J. Hegar that helped launch them into the nationwide highlight.

Putnam’s advertisements for O’Dowd characteristic most of the traits which have made him one of the sought-after inventive minds in his discipline: emotional urgency, first-person testimonials and compelling footage. For a nontraditional marketing campaign topic, they’re pretty arresting.

Putnam’s most up-to-date advert, the one which accuses Musk of operating a “Ponzi scheme,” is almost two minutes lengthy — a unprecedented indulgence for many campaigns.

However O’Dowd’s operation is just not like most campaigns. He doesn’t make use of an official pollster, although he has commissioned polls. He’s not holding marketing campaign rallies or strolling rope strains, although he has held conferences with small teams of voters, curiosity teams and elected officers to air his considerations.

O’Dowd advantages from federal rules that require broadcasters to offer steep reductions to certified candidates for public workplace. Had he arrange a brilliant PAC or another car to underwrite his advertisements, broadcasters would have had extra leeway to refuse them, or to cost hefty charges.

However there’s nothing untoward about what he’s doing, specialists on marketing campaign regulation stated.

“It’s not legally novel to run a single-issue marketing campaign, even when that concern is hyper-focused,” stated Adav Noti, vp and authorized director of the Marketing campaign Authorized Middle. “The regulation is fairly agnostic as to what candidates select to concentrate on.”

The first is arising on June 7. Due to California’s distinctive election legal guidelines, below which the highest two finishers advance to the overall election, O’Dowd could possibly be in a head-to-head matchup with Padilla within the fall.

O’Dowd doesn’t say so explicitly, however he isn’t making an attempt to win, precisely.

“I’m going to restrict myself to those points very fastidiously,” he stated. “And I’m going to inform individuals, you must vote for me if you happen to suppose that is the largest downside.”

O’Dowd insisted that his firm, Inexperienced Hills Software program, is just not a competitor to Tesla.

“We don’t make self-driving vehicles,” he stated, including that some automobile firms had been utilizing its software program in sure low-level elements. “That’s not our enterprise.”

Inexperienced Hills promotes its experience in making specialised software program utilized in automated driving techniques. Its web site says that its code is utilized in “tons of of tens of millions of autos.”

The New York Instances has reported extensively on the shortcomings of Musk’s push for totally autonomous vehicles, together with in a latest documentary movie.

In February, Tesla recalled 54,000 of its vehicles to disable a characteristic of its software program that allowed the autos to make rolling stops in some circumstances. There are complete web sites dedicated to documenting deaths involving Teslas, together with these the place driver-assistance options had been proved to have been concerned.

Once we spoke in late April, O’Dowd stated he had not spoken to Musk about his considerations — although not for lack of making an attempt. “I’ve made three or 4 endeavors to take action by means of mutual mates,” O’Dowd stated. “Belief me, he is aware of who I’m. He is aware of what I do. And he’s not .”

We need to hear from you.
Inform us about your expertise with this text by answering this quick survey.


On Politics repeatedly options work by Instances photographers. Right here’s what Doug Mills instructed us about capturing the picture above:

The picture was taken throughout a information convention in Tokyo with Prime Minister Fumio Kishida of Japan, simply after President Biden stated he was prepared to defend Taiwan with navy drive, if needed. At this second, the president was pondering one other query, however reporters within the room had been buzzing — everybody knew he had simply made the information of the day.

And right here’s what Erin Schaff needed to say about this gorgeous church in Ecuador:

I used to be the only pool photographer for the primary woman’s six-day go to to Latin America. She went to Ecuador, Panama and Costa Rica, on a mission to reaffirm the U.S. dedication to the area prematurely of the Summit of the Americas, which goes to be held in June in Los Angeles.

There’s slightly bit extra freedom for the primary woman in a manner that there isn’t for the president. From a images perspective, it was enjoyable simply to get to see her interacting with youngsters and assembly with numerous different first girls and seeing a little bit of her character.

This Jesuit church we visited in the primary sq. in Quito, Ecuador, is a well-known instance of colonial-era Baroque structure. Locals simply name it “La Compañía.” Once we entered, there was a piano participant taking part in “Ave Maria.” It was very darkish inside, so I had to make use of a slower shutter velocity to seize the golden glow coming off the partitions. It was a extremely stunning second.

Is there something you suppose we’re lacking? Something you need to see extra of? We’d love to listen to from you. Electronic mail us at [email protected].